How to Fire Someone at a Christian Organization – Andrew Smith

Over the course of my career, I’ve participated in more than 190 exits of employees, whether I was coaching a manager, planning upstream, sitting in on calls, or orchestrating layoffs. Each time was tough. Parting ways with an employee is one of the heaviest things a manager does. Doing it both clearly and kindly takes a lot of preparation and emotional regulation.

In a faith-based workplace, these decisions can be even more surprising and hurtful, because managers try to spare the discomfort of a conversation about performance under any number of banners of being “kind.”

How should we think about this as Christians who manage other Christians?

Why Good Work Is Important

A church’s mission is to spread the good news of Jesus, create ways for people to know him more deeply, and love our neighbors. A Christian nonprofit’s purpose is adjacent—to provide mercy, justice, evangelism, or discipleship while pointing people to Christ and their local church.

This work happens through ministry and outreach staff, but also through effective operations. Doing this work takes all types of roles: pastors, administrators, and ministry coordinators; managers, accountants, and musicians; executive admins, facilities operators, and IT teams. Much of what it takes to run a church or Christian organization happens outside the hours of direct ministry.

To do any of this well, churches and nonprofits must hire capable people who can effectively perform their duties and steward the mission. When managers in a secular workplace don’t hire wisely, I’ve seen the result in poor functional performance, departmental infighting, disengagement, acrimonious exits, and abuse of company resources.

In a faith-based organization or church, you may get a mix of this and something worse: the spread of the gospel can be compromised too.

Upstream Work for Managers

As a manager, if you notice someone isn’t performing well, the best time to start talking about it isn’t at the exit conversation. It’s way upstream from that.

Your core job is to ensure your people have what they need to be successful. That includes clear expectations, communication of what success looks like, feedback on performance, and accountability for meeting those standards. Ideally, you’re doing these on a regular basis in one-on-one meetings  and in performance check-ins throughout the year.

Churches and nonprofits must hire capable people who can effectively perform their duties and steward the mission.

This is a manager’s job, and faith-based organizations don’t have a softer standard. Where I’ve seen termination decisions and conversations go south—in Christian organizations or elsewhere—is when a manager doesn’t understand this. (Or, worse, they understand it but think that somehow it doesn’t apply to them.)

Speaking to an employee about parting ways because you’ve consistently documented underperformance is a rough conversation. It’s far worse when your failure to give regular feedback leaves an employee blindsided, confused, and hurt when you need to broach termination.

Often, that failure is rooted in a desire to avoid conflict or hurt feelings. The manager would rather spare himself the discomfort of a direct conversation. In a Christian organization, this impulse pulls hard. The employees under your care all love Jesus. They’re there to promote the church’s mission and spread the gospel. You may even sit shoulder to shoulder in the pews with them on Sundays.

But James 4:17 has a word for managers who fail to do the difficult work: “Whoever knows the right thing to do and fails to do it, for him it is sin.” Colossians 4:1 underlines this: “Masters, treat your bondservants justly and fairly, knowing that you also have a Master in heaven.”

I’ve watched managers avoid the perceived sin of commission (telling someone he’s doing a poor job in his role) and step right into the sin of omission (letting the problem fester until the employee is struggling and a termination conversation seems inevitable). It doesn’t have to be this way. The hard thing and the loving thing aren’t at odds here.

Justice, Mercy, and God’s Sovereignty at Work

Let’s say you have an employee you’ve been coaching and providing with direct feedback about his (or her) performance. You’ve clearly communicated his responsibilities, warned him when he’s failed, given chances for improvement, and clarified what good performance looks like. It’s not a situation of grave moral failure or breach of ethics, just run-of-the-mill underperformance.

What if he doesn’t improve? Are churches or Christian organizations allowed to fire someone for something besides moral failure? Is it fair to let someone go because he isn’t good at his church job?

The short answer: Yes. Faith-based organizations hire people to perform a set of roles and responsibilities that contribute to the thriving of that organization. This means doing the job satisfactorily, abiding by the organization’s codes of conduct, and operating within legal bounds of employment. When someone—regardless of his intentions—fails to consistently meet these expectations, parting ways is a course of action that’s on the table. That’s not callous; it’s a means to preserve the integrity of the organization’s mission.

But letting someone go should be a last resort. Managers can and should be sensitive to giving clear direction and expectations, continual feedback on what’s going well (or not), and a reasonable timeline to make improvements. And sometimes—for legal or other reasons—someone will need reasonable accommodations to get his work done. We need to give people as fair of a shot as possible to succeed.

The worst situation for everyone is where a person is struggling, and the manager hasn’t done anything to intervene because a manager thinks his silent toleration is showing “mercy.” That behavior isn’t justice or mercy—it’s abdicating responsibility as a steward of your employees and your organization’s mission.

But let’s say the manager has done his best to set clear expectations, addressed flagging performance, or provided reasonable accommodations. The employee still doesn’t seem to ever improve. What then?

As managers, it’s easy to worry that termination ruins someone’s life. It’s tempting to want to avoid that conversation and to keep giving him chances to get better (even if he’s shown that’s not possible). But this can become a way to protect the manager from discomfort and a hard decision; it does nothing to benefit the employee.

Silent toleration isn’t justice or mercy—it’s abdicating responsibility as a steward of your employees and your organization’s mission.

When we hold back the hard call, we tell ourselves a story about mercy: I don’t want to be the one who upends this person’s life, so I won’t go there. That’s a heavy burden to put on your shoulders. To believe you’re ruining someone’s life by ending his employment is to believe you hold his future in your hands.

But here’s the thing: You don’t. You aren’t sovereign over this person’s story. You cannot see his next chapter. The assumption that you can, that keeping him in a role where he’s failing is protecting him from some fate only you can foresee, isn’t humility. It’s pride.

We’re obligated to be fair and right and just to the employees in our care (Prov. 2:9, 21:15; Mic. 6:8). Sometimes that means the consequences of one person’s poor behavior at work have to be addressed through parting ways. Remember that God also sees our work, and in his grace he often allows us to suffer the just consequences of our actions. We likewise need to be fair in managing performance even if that involves a hard call.

Sometimes, letting a person go who isn’t performing is a boon to him long-term. It can be the catalyst to propel him to a future role or career where his abilities are better fit for what another organization needs. That’s hard to imagine when you’re in the thick of the situation, but from someone who has seen this play out scores of times, I can assure you it happens.

Communication During Termination

Let’s get to the conversation where you need to sit across from another human and let him know that he will no longer have a job in your organization. Here are three tips:

Do your homework. In the run-up to the conversation, make sure you’ve exhausted all reasonable ways to help this person improve his performance. If you have reliable human-resources partners available, ask them to help you think through all the angles of the decision. Once the decision is made, prepare and rehearse for the conversation. Know what you want to say, and practice saying it.

Speak with calmness and empathy. Just because we have to deliver a direct truth doesn’t mean we have to be heartless and cold. Share what you need to, but don’t give vent to all the ways he’s disappointed you (Ps. 141:3). Speak the truth in love (Eph. 4:15). Be gentle, even if he becomes upset (Prov. 15:1).

Pray. We have recourse to a higher, sovereign power. Ask for God’s grace and peace to flow into your life and into your employee’s life. Ask him to be gracious and show his love and favor to the employee in his next steps (16:9).

We never know the plans that God has for our employees’ lives. And thankfully, we don’t need to. We can submit our decisions and their lives to the Lord and ask for his hand to guide them. Every time I was involved with an employee exit, I’d pray like this:

Dear God, this person is going to hear hard news today. Please protect him from fear and anxiety. Please guide our words so we can be clear and also respectful in relaying our decision. Please guide his steps from here and open up opportunities that will amaze him with your goodness. Use this as a means to draw him close to you and break into his life in incredible ways.

More often than not, I’ve been able to see answers to this prayer materialize before my eyes.

Being a manager is hard. Having to let someone go is one of the hardest parts of the job. And the pressures of a faith-based context can make that even more difficult. If we remember our role, take the responsibility to do it well, believe that God is sovereign, and bring the love of Christ even into hard conversations, we—and our people—will be better off.

Read More

The Gospel Coalition

Generated by Feedzy