Let’s Educate “Professor” Dave Farina on Evolution and Design

[Editor’s Note: This the second of a two-part series from Jonathan McLatchie responding to Dave Farina’s defenses for evolution and objections to Intelligent Design. For part 1 in this series click here]

Is Machine Language Used in the Technical Literature?

Farina remarks,

“Let’s move on to part two, which is about the bacterial flagellum, the honorary mascot of intelligent design. He starts by whining about how I identified the persistent tactic of using terminology related to man-made machines to describe biological systems, to manipulate the viewer into believing these systems were designed. Predictably, Jonny says that everyone talks like this!”

This is not a “persistent tactic” intended “to manipulate the viewer into believing these systems were designed.” The use of machine language to describe biological systems is standard in the scientific literature. Farina alleges that,

“People who aren’t pushing propaganda typically refer to these structures by saying ‘acts as a drive shaft’, or ‘molecular “clutch”’ using quotation marks, to distinguish from a literal clutch. The functions are analogous. There have been numerous papers written to push back against this analogy of cells as machines…” 

To take but a single example, one paper is titled “Structural basis of the bacterial flagellar motor rotational switching.”[1] Here, the term “motor” is used without qualification or quote marks. The same paper states that “The motor is a bidirectional rotary nanomachine” and “the hook functions as a joint that connects the motor to the filament, which acts as a propeller to propel bacteria for swimming in liquid medium and swarming on solid surface. The motor spans both the inner and outer membranes and consists of the basal body and several stator units.” Moreover, “The LP ring acts as a bushing to stabilize the rotation of the rod, which serves as the drive shaft.” Examples of such language in the literature could be multiplied almost endlessly. That Farina is not aware of this indicates his lack of familiarity with the scientific literature.

In Defense of Behe & Snoke

Farina continues,

“But here’s the big whiff for this one. I had taken Behe to school for a paper he wrote with David Snoke where he pretended that his simulation demonstrated the improbability of irreducibly complex traits arising. Here’s Jonny’s response: ‘“Finally, Farina complains that ‘They also specified a pre-determined target sequence and only considered the simulation to have been successful if that specific target evolved.’ But this is incorrect. Rather, the paper provides estimates for how many organisms would be required, and over how long a time frame, for multiple co-dependent mutations (none of which by themselves confers an advantage) to become fixed in a population.’ See what he does there? He states the critique, and then says something completely irrelevant. His response does not in any way address the critique.”

But Behe and Snoke’s simulation does not assume a single magic sequence. Rather, it estimates the time required for the fixation of coordinated changes, where neither of the mutations by itself confers an adaptive advantage. Farina continues,

“That does not refute what I said. It is objectively true that Behe and Snoke specified a target sequence, something that Jonny doesn’t even try to dispute, and that alone invalidates their conclusion, since evolution does not work that way. There are no predetermined goal sequences. Nature is not sentient.”

The point of the paper, though, is to evaluate the time needed to evolve a new functional interaction that requires multiple specific mutations in multicellular organisms.

Farina goes on,

“We have directly, experimentally demonstrated that there are usually many sequences that will do a specific job approximately equally well. For example, a 2018 study found that among random strings of 100 nucleotides, many will function as a promoter in E. coli, some equally as well, or even better than, the wild-type sequence. So setting a predetermined target to determine how fast or slow, or how likely or unlikely something is to evolve completely invalidates whatever conclusion you reach, period.”

This is an extremely weak argument, and it’s not applicable to Behe and Snoke’s paper. First, they specifically looked at evolution in multicellular organisms, not bacteria. So, any examples from E. coli bacteria don’t address the paper’s arguments. Second, promoters are relatively simple sequences that recruit RNA polymerase and basic transcription factors. They are short and many different sequences can do the job. A functional promoter is relatively easy to find in sequence space. On the other hand, protein-protein binding interfaces require highly specific and complementary shapes. A random DNA sequence is far more likely to weakly promote transcription than two proteins are to randomly evolve a new binding interface.

Shifting Fitness Landscapes

Farina comments,

“Moving on to number three, we go from Behe’s first garbage book, Darwin’s Black Box, to his second garbage book, The Edge of Evolution, and Jonny doesn’t do any better here. Remember that tactic from a minute ago, where he just repeats the critique, and then follows it with something completely unrelated? He does that again here. He quotes my explanation for how Behe butchers the concept of fitness landscapes, and then responds with this: ‘But for many complex adaptations, such as those described in Behe’s books, a fitness benefit is not realized until multiple co-dependent mutations have arisen. That is exactly what both Behe and Jonny get wrong about this. That sentence is only true if the fitness landscape doesn’t change.”

While Farina’s point about shifting fitness landscapes is valid when discussing changing environments (what is disadvantageous in one environment, might be beneficial in another), it does not refute Behe’s argument. Of course, fitness landscapes can change. However, for many complex features, adaptations require multiple coordinated mutations, even in dynamic environments. Farina essentially admits this when he argues that there were multiple neutral potentiating mutations required to evolve the Cit+ phenotype. He was wrong in that case to claim that the potentiating mutations were required for the Cit+ trait, but the point is Farina knows that there can be cases where multiple mutations are necessary before you gain any advantage. Thus, even Farina knows that Behe’s framing is not invalid.

Farina states,

“For example, if a mutation makes an enzyme less stable, then it may become compatible with different substrates, since its structure will be more flexible. In an environment with only one target molecule, this would then be harmful. But if a second target becomes available, meaning if the fitness landscape changes, then that mutation may be beneficial under the new conditions. Pretty easy to grasp, huh? Just a quick reminder, Jonny has a doctorate in evolutionary biology. There’s no way he doesn’t understand this. He’s shilling for the DI for cash.”

But in order for a complex feature that requires multiple specific co-dependent mutations, the landscape must change in precisely the right way at the right time – after the realization of the first mutation but before it is lost to genetic drift or purifying selection. And the same thing must happen again after the second mutation. And so on.

Vpu Revisited

In my original article, I had noted that Farina cited the Vpu example as a counter-example to Behe’s claim concerning HIV that “there have been no significant basic biological changes in the virus at all” and “there have been no reports of new viral protein-protein interactions developing in an infected cell due to mutations in HIV proteins.” As Behe acknowledged years ago, this was in fact one example he had previously overlooked. I noted that this does not significantly impact Behe’s central thesis, since one may modify the statement to assert that “There have been hardly any reports…” Farina responds, “It’s actually pretty great that he admits this, because the difference between ‘none’ and ‘hardly any’ is the difference between Behe being right and Behe being full of [expletive].”

To my knowledge, this is the only instance that may be cited as a counter-example to Behe’s claim (if Farina or anyone else knows of another counter-example, then I would be interested to see it). This is particularly striking given how extensively studied and well characterized the HIV virus is. Since the 1980s, tens of thousands of scientific papers have been published on the HIV virus, and hundreds of thousands of HIV genomes have been sequenced from patients globally. If evolution is capable of producing complex molecular interactions, the place where we would most expect to find them is in viruses like HIV, with their massive population sizes, fast mutation rates, and rapid generation time. If it is difficult even in HIV to evolve a new protein-protein binding site, all the more is it a problem when it comes to bacteria and simple eukaryotes, let alone more complex organisms like mammals!

Dave Farina Misunderstands Darwin Devolves

In this final section, I will engage with Farina’s comments regarding my defense of Behe’s most recent book, Darwin Devolves.

Farina remarks,

“Finally we get to the fourth one, which is about Behe’s third and arguably dumbest book, Darwin Devolves. This is the one that botches super basic concepts in genetics so badly that it becomes painfully obvious that Behe is lying… the entire book is based on the singular insane lie that mutations ‘degrade information’ in the genome and are somehow destructive. Of course this is meaningless, and simply meant to take advantage of people who have no idea what mutation means or even what DNA is.”

This is a caricature of Behe’s thesis. Behe does not claim that all mutations are harmful to the organism. Indeed, most mutations are in fact neutral, a point Behe happily acknowledges in his book (see for example pp. 96-98 of Darwin Devolves where Behe states “neutral mutations are the bulk of changes at the molecular level”.[2] Rather, Behe’s thesis is that beneficial mutations (which accounts for a small minority of all mutations) are heavily biased toward loss-of-function – that is, degradation of existing genetic information. This thesis is not just correct, but supported by extensive data from population genetics. There are vastly more ways to gain an advantage by breaking functional genetic elements than there are ways to gain an advantage by building a new, complex feature. Therefore, natural selection will always “find” the destructive, but beneficial, mutations (of which there are many more in number) long before it “finds” the constructive beneficial mutations (which are far rarer). This presents a formidable challenge to the idea that complex organisms have arisen from a simple single-celled progenitor, via entirely unguided processes.

Farina continues,

“Even with simple point mutations, which don’t ‘degrade’ anything, they just potentially alter the products of gene expression, the results are varied. But more importantly, there are large scale mutations that I mentioned in the Behe debunk, like gene duplication and neofunctionalization, as well as de novo genes, which produce completely new proteins without losing any genetic material or existing functionality. Every biology undergraduate student in the world knows this.”

Nobody in this debate is denying that constructive mutations, gene duplications and de novo (i.e., taxonomically-restricted) genes exist. Rather, Behe’s argument in Darwin Devolves is that beneficial mutations are heavily biased towards degradation or loss-of-function. This is an empirical fact. There are vastly more ways to acquire an advantage by breaking a gene than there are to do so by building a genuinely new function. The implication of this fact must not be lost: blind evolution via random mutation and natural selection will tend to break or diminish functions at a much faster rate than it builds them. This means Darwinism faces a fundamental problem. A majority of gene duplications are lost to purifying selection or become pseudogenes. Successful neofunctionalization depends on a series of specific mutations that confer novel selectable function while preserving the original copy. In bacteria in particular, there is a significant time limit for neofunctionalization to occur since there is an energetic cost in carrying and transcribing a broken gene.[3] [4]

In the case of de novo genes, their envisaged origin from non-coding DNA is typically assumed rather than demonstrated. Requirements for this to work include a functional open reading frame, a promoter, proper level and timing of expression, correct protein folding, and integration into existing cellular networks.

Citing mechanisms known to every undergraduate does not address the quantitative data, emphasized by Behe and others, on the rarity of constructive change relative to degradative change.

Farina goes on,

“Let’s see how little Jonny tries to play it off. First, he tries to cover up the fact that Behe himself provided a counter-example to his own thesis with the C-Harlem variant of hemoglobin, and this mess is how he tries to do that: ‘Surprisingly, however, ‘the C-Harlem gene, which builds directly on the foundation of the sickle gene and would entirely eliminate the drawbacks of the sickle mutation, has not yet turned up in Africa, where it would do the most good.’ The reason for this is that the move from regular hemoglobin to C-Harlem would require two co-dependent mutations, whereas the sickle-cell trait requires only one.’

Again, we see Jonny’s strategy of ‘ignore the critique and say something unrelated’, which almost always turns out to be some variant of ‘but it’s really unlikely!’.

That doesn’t matter. Behe’s whole argument is based on the idea that non-reductive beneficial traits never evolve. But here we have an example of such a trait that he himself described in his book.
How frequently we expect it to evolve is completely irrelevant to the question of whether it exists.
And if we want to take this non-response seriously, it clearly evolved at least once, since we’ve documented its existence. Then he whines about 
Cit+ again, and says literally nothing.”

Again, Farina is repeating a strawman. Behe does not claim that no constructive traits evolve. Rather, the claim is that beneficial mutations are biased in favor of degradative changes rather than constructive ones. Farina did not address my remarks on C-Harlem from the previous article – the article he is supposed to be responding to. So, I shall simply repeat what I wrote there.

The C-Harlem example actually supports Behe over Farina. As Behe explains in The Edge of Evolution, “Hereditary persistence of fetal hemoglobin (HPFH) is already widespread in Africa, ameliorating the problems of the sickle gene.”[5] Surprisingly, however, “the C-Harlem gene, which builds directly on the foundation of the sickle gene and would entirely eliminate the drawbacks of the sickle mutation, has not yet turned up in Africa, where it would do the most good.”[6] The reason for this is that the move from regular hemoglobin to C-Harlem would require two co-dependent mutations, whereas the sickle-cell trait requires only one. The probability of getting the sickle-celled trait in any individual is about one in a hundred million. Assuming a population size of a million people, it should thus be expected to arise spontaneously approximately every hundred generations, which is within the reach of evolutionary processes. For the two necessary mutations needed for hemoglobin C-Harlem to occur at the same time, the probability is a hundred million multiplied by a hundred million, which is 1016. As Behe summarizes, “With a generation time of ten years and an average population size of a million people, on average it should take about a hundred billion years for that particular mutation to arise — more than the age of the universe.”[7] Nonetheless, hemoglobin C-Harlem has arisen, and was first documented relatively recently in New York City.[8] [12] But this is because the initial sickle-cell trait was already adaptive, since it conferred resistance to the malarial parasite. Thus, natural selection can preserve the sickle-celled trait (requiring only a single mutation) first and then acquire the second mutation (building on the first), thereby giving rise to the C-Harlem trait, which confers an even greater advantage. The C-Harlem example, therefore, in fact supports Behe’s thesis rather than Farina’s.

A Disappointing Showing from Farina

Farina’s video response to my previous article series is characterized by misrepresentations of the literature he is citing, selective engagement with my own points, and reliance on insults and name-calling. He repeatedly and quietly drops major points on which he was shown to be incorrect.

Neither Behe, nor I, have denied the ability of evolution to produce small-scale adaptations, regulatory changes, or even occasional constructive mutations. Rather, we contend that there are definable limits to what the theory of evolution can accomplish. In particular, we would contend (and this is the main thesis of Behe’s book, Darwin Devolves) that most beneficial mutations involve degradation of existing information and that complex, integrated molecular systems can only be brought about by coordinated changes that exhaust the probabilistic resources afforded by population genetics.

References: 

[1] Tan J, Zhang L, Zhou X, Han S, Zhou Y, Zhu Y. Structural basis of the bacterial flagellar motor rotational switching. Cell Res. 2024 Nov;34(11):788-801. doi: 10.1038/s41422-024-01017-z. Epub 2024 Aug 23. PMID: 39179739; PMCID: PMC11528121.

[2] Behe, MJ. Darwin Devolves: The New Science About DNA That Challenges Evolution (p. 98). HarperCollins. Kindle Edition.

[3] Kuo CH, Ochman H. The extinction dynamics of bacterial pseudogenes. PLoS Genet. 2010 Aug 5;6(8):e1001050. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgen.1001050. PMID: 20700439; PMCID: PMC2916853.

[4] Gauger AK, Ebnet S, Fahey PF, Seelke R (2010) Reductive evolution can prevent populations from taking simple adaptive paths to high fitness. BIO-Complexity 2010(2): 1-9.

[5] Behe MJ, The Edge of Evolution: The Search for the Limits of Darwinism (Free Press, 2007), 29.

[6] Ibid.

[7] Ibid., 110.

[8] Bookchin RM, Nagel RL, Ranney HM. Structure and properties of hemoglobin C-Harlem, a human hemoglobin variant with amino acid substitutions in 2 residues of the beta-polypeptide chain. J Biol Chem. 1967 Jan 25;242(2):248-55. PMID: 6016610.

Recommended Resources:

Why Science Needs God by Dr. Frank Turek (Mp4) 

Science Doesn’t Say Anything, Scientists Do by Dr. Frank Turek (Mp3 and Mp4) 

Oh, Why Didn’t I Say That? Does Science Disprove God? by Dr. Frank Turek (Mp4) 

Stealing From God by Dr. Frank Turek (Book, 10-Part DVD Set, STUDENT Study Guide, TEACHER Study Guide) 

 

Dr. Jonathan McLatchie is a Christian writer, international speaker, and debater. He holds a Bachelor’s degree (with Honors) in forensic biology, a Masters’s (M.Res) degree in evolutionary biology, a second Master’s degree in medical and molecular bioscience, and a Ph.D. in evolutionary biology. Currently, he is an assistant professor of biology at Sattler College in Boston, Massachusetts. Dr. McLatchie is a contributor to various apologetics websites and is the founder of the Apologetics Academy (Apologetics-Academy.org), a ministry that seeks to equip and train Christians to persuasively defend the faith through regular online webinars, as well as assist Christians who are wrestling with doubts. Dr. McLatchie has participated in more than thirty moderated debates around the world with representatives of atheism, Islam, and other alternative worldview perspectives. He has spoken internationally in Europe, North America, and South Africa promoting an intelligent, reflective, and evidence-based Christian faith. 

 

Originally posted at: https://bit.ly/48qYCPF

The post Let’s Educate “Professor” Dave Farina on Evolution and Design appeared first on CrossExamined.

Read More

CrossExamined

Generated by Feedzy