Let’s Educate “Professor” Dave Farina on Evolution and Design

Three years ago, I published a series of four articles (part 1, part 2, part 3, part 4) engaging with Dave Farina who had published a video critique of biochemist Michael Behe’s three books, Darwin’s Black Box, The Edge of Evolution, and Darwin Devolves. Farina, though not holding a terminal degree in any field, is a popular YouTuber, He is a rather sad example of today’s low-quality Darwin defender.

Now, I am no credentialist, and I would not draw attention to Farina’s lack of a terminal degree were it not for the fact that he styles himself as “Professor Dave,” despite neither holding a doctoral degree in any discipline nor having a professorship position. Farina’s lack of an advanced degree does not even by itself form my opinion of his competence in the subjects that he addresses on his channel. As an expert, however, in some of the subjects Farina engages with, it is painfully apparent that Farina lacks expertise on these topics. I am not the only one to have this impression of Farina’s material. I know Jim Tour arrived at a similar conclusion regarding Farina’s interaction with Tour’s own subject matter.

When Farina posted his reply video to my article series, I was distinctly unimpressed by Farina’s handling of the literature he was citing and with his interaction with my written material. His rhetoric was also disproportional to his command of the subject matter. I was therefore disinclined to engage any further with him. Our prior engagement on Twitter also revealed him to be impossible to have a serious scholarly interaction with. For example, he wrote, “Get ready for the top search result for your name on both Google and YouTube being me taking a big steamy dump all over your dumb science denying apologist face.” These are not the words of an intellectually serious person.

Though the errors in Farina’s presentation are easy for the trained eye to spot, not everybody has the academic expertise to identify his many mistakes. Occasionally I have had people ask me for my thoughts on Farina’s critique of me. I have therefore decided that a response to Farina’s video might be instructive for some. In this and subsequent articles, I will address each of Farina’s points from his video.

Farina’s Failure to Acknowledge Mistakes

In my previous article series, I had highlighted multiple items on which Farina is straightforwardly wrong. Rather than engaging with these points or acknowledging correction, Farina chose to simply drop them entirely, focusing instead only on those items which he thought he could rebut. Doubtless many of the viewers of his video will not have bothered to look back on my original article series to see how many of his earlier points Farina subtly drops entirely from his response – points that, as I showed in my previous series, were straightforwardly wrong.

Perhaps the most significant howler in Farina’s previous video, which he entirely dropped in his rebuttal, is Farina’s mistaken claim that scientists observed a flagellum evolve in real-time. Behe had asked in a 2016 article,

“[W]hy doesn’t [Kenneth Miller] just take an appropriate bacterial species, knock out the genes for its flagellum, place the bacterium under selective pressure (for mobility, say), and experimentally produce a flagellum — or any equally complex system — in the laboratory? (A flagellum, after all, has only 30-40 genes, not the hundreds Miller claims would be easy for natural selection to rapidly redesign.) If he did that, my claims would be utterly falsified. But he won’t even try it because he is grossly exaggerating the prospects of success.”

Farina commented,

“Hilariously, [Behe] is oblivious to the fact that this precise experiment was carried out the year before. Here’s the paper. Gene deletion produced two strains of bacteria with no flagellum. They then introduced selective pressure for motility by depleting the nutrients in the colony. Within 96 hours, both strains had regenerated flagellar motility by a pathway involving two successive point mutations in genes that served other purposes.”

As I noted in my original article addressing Farina, the paper that Farina cites does not do this at all.[1]  I stated in my earlier essay that I am skeptical that Farina even took the time to read the article, beyond the title, before citing it. Farina has done nothing with his more recent rebuttal to assuage these concerns. All that the researchers deleted was the flagellar master switch protein, FleQ, in Pseudomonas fluorescens. After a few days of incubating the bacterial cells on Petri dishes, they reacquired their ability to grow flagella. The genetic basis for this reactivation of the flagella is that another master switch protein, NtrC, that is a structurally similar homolog of FleQ — responsible for turning on genes involved in nitrogen metabolism — already had the ability, to some extent, to cross-bind to the promoter usually bound by FleQ. When produced in excess, as a result of a broken regulator, NtrC was thus able to drive flagellar synthesis. As a consequence of this mutation, the bacterial cell lost its ability to regulate its nitrogen metabolism genes.

Thus, contrary to the Farina video’s claims, this paper does not document the de novo evolutionary origins of a bacterial flagellum at all — far from it. In fact, Behe has already addressed the paper here. Once again, Farina failed to address or even mention these points in his more recent video where he is supposedly responding to my rebuttal. He just dropped this example and refused to admit that he was completely wrong.

Another significant error that Farina dropped entirely relates to the malarial parasite. In particular, Farina had previously stated that “it’s quite amusing to note that if Behe considers [antimalarial] drug resistance to be impossible to evolve, it means that he believes in a god who deliberately bestowed plasmodia with resistance to our drugs in order to ensure that we continue to contract malaria. Gee, what a swell guy.” As I wrote in my previous essay addressing this aspect of Farina’s critique of Behe, though, this betrays a misunderstanding of what Behe argues in The Edge of Evolution. He does not deny that malarial parasites have acquired resistance to chloroquine and other antimalarial drugs. Quite the contrary. Rather, he notes that malarial resistance to chloroquine has arisen and that it occurs approximately once in every 1020 cells. He then uses this data to extrapolate to a case requiring twice as many co-dependent changes to bring about, and he points out that this problem is far more acute in the case of more complex organisms like large mammals, with much smaller population sizes, longer generation turn-over times, and lower mutation rates. Casey Luskin called out Nathan Lents who made the exact same error about Behe, and Farina seems to have basically mimicked Lents’s total error in full. This is a straightforward error on Farina’s part, and Farina fails to even acknowledge it.

Another example which Farina quietly dropped in his rebuttal, though this one is more of an error of interpretation rather than of fact, is his claim that there are animals that consume photosynthetic algae “which appear to be on their way to becoming photosynthetic themselves via endosymbiosis.” In support of this contention, Farina cited a paper on “Horizontal gene transfer of the algal nuclear gene psbO to the photosynthetic sea slug Elysia chlorotica.”[2] As I noted in my original response, the paper discusses the acquisition of plastids by the sea slug Elysia chlorotica by ingestion of the photosynthetic algae Vaucheria litorea. Though more than 90 percent of the proteins required for plastid metabolism are encoded in the nuclear genome of the algae, the plastids are nonetheless still able to photosynthesize within the sea slug. The paper determines that the essential plastid proteins are supplied by the sea slug itself, and that the genes which support photosynthesis have been acquired through horizontal gene transfer. But this does not involve the evolution of any new complex traits. The genes and proteins already existed but were simply transferred from one organism to another. Farina did not revisit this example in his response video.

A further claim Farina failed to revisit is his statement in his previous video that “There are the unicellular algae that evolved in the lab to become permanently multicellular,” citing a paper by Herron et al. (2018) — “De novo origins of multicellularity in response to predation.”[3] In the study, populations of the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii were subjected to selective pressure by the introduction of the filter-feeding predator Paramecium tetraurelia. They found that two of the five populations developed multicellular structures. However, the multicellular populations lacked motility and the multicellular structures did not evolve multiple cell types. Moreover, as the authors of the paper note, “The ability of wild-type C. reinhardtii to form palmelloids [i.e. multicellular structures] suggests that the founding population in our experiment already possessed a toolkit for producing multicellular structures.” While the strains that evolved in the experiment are obligately multicellular (meaning that being composed of multiple cells is an essential and permanent part of their life cycle), the authors suggest that the genetic basis of the evolved multicellularity phenotype “involves the co-option of a previously existing plastic response.” If this is the case, the authors note, “the shift from a primarily unicellular (but facultatively multicellular) to an obligately multicellular life cycle may have required only a change from facultative to obligate expression of the genes involved in palmelloid formation.” In other words, the transition from being able to exist as single-celled organisms, while forming multicellular structures under certain conditions, to being permanently multicellular may have involved a shift from being able to turn the relevant genes on or off to the genes being permanently locked on. In essence, at best this cannot be an example of evolving something new, but simply an example of a pre-existing trait being turned on permanently. Nothing new actually evolved.

Failing to acknowledge mistakes when they are pointed out to you is one of the surest signs of “soldier mindset” – a mindset more concerned with defending one’s side than with arriving at the truth and refining one’s map of reality. A true scout mindset, by contrast, invites the correction of errors, because truth takes precedence over preserving appearances of scoring rhetorical points.

Revisiting the Lenski Experiment

Farina offers the Lenski experiment as a purported counter-example to irreducible complexity (see my previous article engaging this topic). In Richard Lenski’s long-term evolution experiment (LTEE) with Escherichia coli, it was famously observed that, following some 33,000 generations (15 years), bacterial cells evolved the ability to grow on citrate under aerobic conditions. The genetic basis for this is that E. coli already possesses the ability to grow on citrate under anaerobic conditions, facilitated by a citrate transporter protein encoded by the gene citT. A 2933 base pair stretch of DNA, containing the citT gene, underwent duplication. The result was that a copy of the hitherto unexpressed citT gene was placed under the control of the promoter of the adjacent gene, rnk, which as a consequence drove expression under aerobic conditions.

Farina contends that,

“A particular strain evolved an attribute that qualifies as irreducibly complex according to Behe’s own definition… This experiment produced a strain of bacteria that was able to digest citrate in an aerobic environment, and in order to do this it required multiple mutations in both the dctA gene and citT gene, and a duplication of the citT gene into a new region of the genome. All of these changes were required, and none of them can have been selected for individually. In fact, the critical duplication is actually deleterious on its own without the other mutations. So according to Behe’s own definition, it is irreducibly complex, yet we watched it evolve.”

While multiple changes are required for the efficient Cit+ trait, biologist Scott Minnich and colleagues showed that the process is stepwise, conferring a selective advantage at each stage. An initial weak benefit is realized by amplification of citT via gene duplication. This allows limited citrate uptake during aerobic conditions. Aerobic expression of citT is then strongly activated by promoter capture, yielding a functional Cit+ phenotype. Subsequent refinement of the dctA gene yields a further advantage by bringing succinate back into the cell that was leaking out. Farina’s claim that “none can have been selected individually” is factually incorrect.

Misapplying Irreducible Complexity

Farina also misapplies biochemist Michael Behe’s definition of irreducible complexity. According to Behe, “By irreducibly complex I mean a single system composed of several well-matched, interacting parts that contribute to the basic function, wherein the removal of any one of the parts causes the system to effectively cease functioning.”[4] In such a system, no stepwise paths exist in which each intermediate stage confers a selective benefit. This standard is not met by the Cit+ trait. As shown in the Minnich paper, each stage confers a selective advantage. Moreover, the Minnich paper explicitly states that “No new genetic information (novel gene function) evolved.” This is merely an example of repurposing pre-existing transporters, not the origins of a novel irreducibly complex system.

Farina continues,

“How is Jonny gonna deal with this one? Surprise, surprise, he lies. He pretends that the only change was duplication of the citT gene. A ‘relatively simple change that does not require multiple co-dependent mutations to bring it about’. Except it does, Jonny.”

No, I did not assert that “the only change was a duplication of the citT gene.” In fact, I specifically noted that “the ability of the cells to grow on citrate under aerobic conditions was optimized by several other mutations.” The key point of the Minnich paper, however, was that this adaptation does not require a series of prerequisite neutral mutations as Lenski and his colleagues had assumed.

Misunderstanding the Minnich Paper

Farina continues,

“The first paper that demonstrated the complexity of the Cit+ trait was ‘A case study in evolutionary contingency’ by Zachary Blount, published in 2016, which showed that additional mutations occurred in the history of the Cit+ line that allowed the Cit+ trait to actually occur. But ironically, as we mentioned in the Behe debunk, a lot of the details of the Cit+ trait were fleshed out in another 2016 paper, called ‘Rapid Evolution of Citrate Utilization by Escherichia coli by Direct Selection Requires citT and dctA’, co-authored by one of Jonny’s DI colleagues, Scott Minnich. In this paper, Minnich and his co-authors identified a set of specific mutations that are necessary for the Cit+ trait to evolve. Minnich and other DI hacks tout this study to try and undercut the weight of what the LTEE demonstrated, claiming ‘Hey, it’s actually really easy to evolve Cit+ under the right conditions, so it’s no big deal!’, when what they’ve actually done is show just how readily irreducibly complex traits can evolve, completely demolishing the biggest argument in their pathetic arsenal.”

Farina’s representation of the Minnich paper is extremely misleading. The whole point of the Minnich paper is that the LTEE result was an artifact of experimental conditions rather than a rare event. The prior neutral mutations are not necessary for potentiation – the only requirement is citT amplification. As Minnich and his colleagues showed, this can happen in as few as twelve generations.

Farina further writes,

“He [McLatchie] even references the Minnich paper only to completely contradict himself, outright stating that three steps were highlighted, the first involving neutral mutations which are necessary for the later actualization event.

That’s how confident he is that nobody reading has a clue what he’s talking about.
The self-contradiction is blatant. So when you pretend that it was just a duplication of the citT gene and nothing else, that’s called a lie. You know, those things that liars tell? You’re a liar, Jonny.”

But it is Farina, not me, who is mistaken. I did not claim that “nothing else” happened (in fact, I said the opposite). When I discussed the three steps of potentiation, actualization, and refinement, this was specifically in the context of describing Lenski’s original interpretation. Lenski’s group believed that as many as 33,000 generations were required for the trait to evolve due to the need for the rare prior neutral mutations (i.e., the potentiation step). The Minnich paper argued, contrary to this interpretation, the prior potentiating mutations are not required. Rather, gene amplification, via duplication, of the citT gene yields a benefit immediately, without preceding contingent mutations.

We now turn our attention to Farina’s discussion of the Vpu protein in HIV-1 as a counter-example to Behe’s thesis in The Edge of Evolution.

On Vpu

Farina remarks,

“Another example I mentioned in the Behe debunk is the VPU protein in HIV-1. It evolved the ability to counteract part of the human immune system that’s different from other apes, a completely new function, without losing its ancestral function.”

Farina’s representation of this example is factually accurate. However, this adaptation was achieved through minor modification of an existing viral protein (specifically, changes to the transmembrane domain) rather than de novo creation of a new protein. As I noted in my previous article addressing Farina, Vigan & Neil mapped the key changes to specific residues (in particular, A14, W22, and to a lesser extent A18) in the transmembrane domain. These residues cluster on one face of the alpha helix and are crucial for tetherin interaction and antagonism. Farina responds,

“Jonny attempts damage control here too. First he references a completely different paper which investigates only one region of the protein, instead of the paper I referenced which investigates two regions, specifying that adaptations in both of these regions are required for the novel activity. The paper Jonny pivoted to examines only one of these. Creationist cherry picking at its finest.”

However, while changes in both segments of the transmembrane domain do contribute to optimal function, the strongest effects come from the central cluster (especially A14 and W22). Mutations affecting the N-terminal segment have weaker effects and mostly contribute to efficiency rather than being strictly critical. Indeed, beyond the three amino acid modifications I referred to in my previous article (and above), no other residue changes are required for the core tetherin-antagonism function of HIV-1 Vpu.

Farina further comments,

“It’s also worth noting that another study looking at a different HIV subgroup, HIV-1N, showed four amino acid substitutions that activated VPU against human tetherin, which are totally different from the ones in the study on HIV-1M. So this example also debunks another classic creationist straw man, the idea that there is only one way to get a particular function. Two different sets of mutations yielding the same novel function in two different subgroups of the virus. Isn’t it lovely when one example debunks two creationist talking points at the same time?”

It is true that having multiple combinations that achieve a complex adaptation increases the probability of finding one of them by chance. However, as the number of required co-dependent mutations for a selective benefit to be realized, the probability that there are alternative combinations decreases.

Consider that, for a two-residue interaction, the number of possibilities is 202, or 400. For a 3-residue interaction, the number jumps to 203, or eight thousand. For a 4-residue interaction, the combinatorial space is as high as 204, or 160,000. For a 5-residue interaction, the number of possibilities is 205, or 3.2 million. Unless the number of solutions grows proportionally, the fraction of adaptive combinations drops dramatically.

Farina further states,

“After that Jonny decides to whine about how none of it matters and this example doesn’t count, because it’s in viruses which mutate so rapidly. No fair! Ok then, moron.”

Farina’s dismissal of this important point suggests that he does not understand the subject of population genetics very well. Viruses such as HIV have enormous effective population sizes, very high mutation rates, and extremely short generation turn-over times. These render multi-mutation effects vastly more probable than in bacteria, let alone multicellular organisms such as animals. If complex adaptations can happen anywhere, they are most likely to occur in viruses. Even this particular case is not especially impressive given the highly optimal conditions for viral evolution relative to higher life-forms.

Has Dave Farina Refuted Behe & Me on the Bacterial Flagellum?

As I noted earlier in this article, Farina had previously claimed that scientists had observed a flagellum evolve in real-time. I documented in a previous article (the one to which Farina is supposedly responding) that Farina had completely misinterpreted the paper. Rather than acknowledge correction, however, Farina chose to entirely drop this point in his most recent response.

In any case, let us review what Farina did in fact say in response to other aspects of my critique.

 *** Stay Tuned for Part 2 in this series ***

References:

[1] Taylor TB, Mulley G, Dills AH, Alsohim AS, McGuffin LJ, Studholme DJ, Silby MW, Brockhurst MA, Johnson LJ, Jackson RW. Evolution. Evolutionary resurrection of flagellar motility via rewiring of the nitrogen regulation system. Science. 2015 Feb 27;347(6225):1014-7. doi: 10.1126/science.1259145. PMID: 25722415.

[2] Rumpho ME, Worful JM, Lee J, Kannan K, Tyler MS, Bhattacharya D, Moustafa A, Manhart JR. Horizontal gene transfer of the algal nuclear gene psbO to the photosynthetic sea slug Elysia chlorotica. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008 Nov 18;105(46):17867-71. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0804968105. Epub 2008 Nov 11. PMID: 19004808; PMCID: PMC2584685.

[3] Herron MD, Borin JM, Boswell JC, Walker J, Chen IK, Knox CA, Boyd M, Rosenzweig F, Ratcliff WC. De novo origins of multicellularity in response to predation. Sci Rep. 2019 Feb 20;9(1):2328. doi: 10.1038/s41598-019-39558-8. PMID: 30787483; PMCID: PMC6382799.

[4] Behe MJ. Darwin’s Black Box: The Biochemical Challenge to Evolution . Simon & Schuster UK. Kindle Edition.

Recommended Resources:

Why Science Needs God by Dr. Frank Turek (Mp4) 

Science Doesn’t Say Anything, Scientists Do by Dr. Frank Turek (Mp3 and Mp4) 

Oh, Why Didn’t I Say That? Does Science Disprove God? by Dr. Frank Turek (Mp4) 

Stealing From God by Dr. Frank Turek (Book, 10-Part DVD Set, STUDENT Study Guide, TEACHER Study Guide) 

 

Dr. Jonathan McLatchie is a Christian writer, international speaker, and debater. He holds a Bachelor’s degree (with Honors) in forensic biology, a Masters’s (M.Res) degree in evolutionary biology, a second Master’s degree in medical and molecular bioscience, and a Ph.D. in evolutionary biology. Currently, he is an assistant professor of biology at Sattler College in Boston, Massachusetts. Dr. McLatchie is a contributor to various apologetics websites and is the founder of the Apologetics Academy (Apologetics-Academy.org), a ministry that seeks to equip and train Christians to persuasively defend the faith through regular online webinars, as well as assist Christians who are wrestling with doubts. Dr. McLatchie has participated in more than thirty moderated debates around the world with representatives of atheism, Islam, and other alternative worldview perspectives. He has spoken internationally in Europe, North America, and South Africa promoting an intelligent, reflective, and evidence-based Christian faith. 

 

Originally posted at: https://bit.ly/48qYCPF

The post Let’s Educate “Professor” Dave Farina on Evolution and Design appeared first on CrossExamined.

Read More

CrossExamined

Generated by Feedzy