What Roman History Can (and Can’t) Explain About Christianity – Andrew Wilson

Of all the paradoxes and tensions in Rome’s Age of Revolution, none is so striking as the contrast between the book and its dustcover. That’s not the fault of the author, Tim Whitmarsh, currently regius professor of Greek at the University of Cambridge. Nor is it unheard of for publishers to exaggerate the novelty, originality, controversy, or even scandal of a particular thesis, especially when promoting scholarly arguments to a wider audience.

But it jars nonetheless. And it has the unfortunate effect of creating undeliverable expectations, which turn a clear, brief, well-written, thoughtful, and perfectly reasonable book into a slight disappointment.

“This remarkable book redefines early Christianity,” proclaims the first endorsement on the back cover. “Dazzling. This thrilling and elegantly written book will change how you see Rome, and Christianity, for ever,” says the next.

The breathlessness continues. Harry Sidebottom says it “makes us rethink everything we know about the rise of Christianity.” Candida Moss commends it for “for ever changing how we think about the entanglement of empire, culture and early Christianity.” The inside jacket has fewer references to “everything” and “for ever,” but praise for the book’s originality continues: “Offers a whole new way to view Christians as an integrated part of the whole, multifaceted ancient Mediterranean world.” And so forth.

There’s nothing wrong with rave reviews and ringing endorsements, of course. The problem in this case is that they lead the reader to anticipate a fresh, bold, provocative, and potentially explosive new argument, which is exactly what Rome’s Age of Revolution: Augustus, Empire, and the Making of Christianity doesn’t provide.

What it offers instead is a measured, straightforward, run-of-the-mill presentation of a widely accepted view—that Christianity “was decisively and fundamentally shaped by the culture that incubated it” (228), both Greek and Roman, and “could not have come into being in anything like the form we know it without the revolutionary impact of Augustus’ political reforms” (230)—to a nonspecialist audience.

Little in here is new, or claims to be. Plenty of it is found embryonically in Eusebius, Chrysostom, Thomas Aquinas, and John Calvin, to say nothing of F. F. Bruce or N. T. Wright.

Integration and Conflict

Whitmarsh revels in nuance, not controversy. “From one perspective, Christianity changed everything. From another, it reflected the world around it” (xxiv).

It would be simplistic, for example, to frame an argument in terms of Greco-Roman cultural influence on early Christianity, because influence flows both ways. It would be equally simplistic to point out all the ways in which the ante-Nicene church aped and adapted imperial Rome without noting the ways in which they had nothing to do with each other: “There was very little that was Augustan about, for example, the Eucharist” (231).

Similarly, although “most Christians were fully integrated into Roman society, and no more or less harassed than anyone else” (184), and although many stories of Christian martyrdom were stylized, embellished, or even invented, there’s no doubt that emperors like Decius and Diocletian pursued “systematic, pan-imperial action” and “vindictively anti-Christian policies” (186) and that “Christian zealots were certainly executed” (204). His analogy is apt:

Although we know that the representation of cowboys and Indians in a western movie is usually a cinematic distortion, it would be a mistake to assume on that basis that conflict between settlers and indigenous peoples in North America in the nineteenth century was entirely the invention of Hollywood. (203–4)

The book is at its best in parts 1 and 2, when describing the endlessly fascinating world of the late Roman republic and early Roman empire, and the ways in which it made Christianity’s message comprehensible and its expansion possible.

Roman Influence on Christianity

The universal access to the gospel, for instance, would’ve been hard to imagine without the award of citizenship to all free males on the Italian peninsula, which is the moment “when Roman identity ceased to be tied geographically to the city of Rome itself, and began to be associated more with loyalty to an idea” (4).

The book is at its best when describing the ways in which the Roman world made Christianity’s message comprehensible and its expansion possible.

The story of Luke-Acts is that of a Roman road trip, set in a world in which Homeric seaways have been replaced by Augustan highways. The paradigmatic Christian form of literature was the letter, which likewise depended on safe roads, milestones, and transport infrastructure. We could go on: Roman laws, aqueducts, bridges, provinces, and architecture all reconfigured the concept of space in ways that shaped the early Christian movement.

In related ways, “Augustus’ revolution reset time as well as space” (77). The arrival of Augustus signified a new world order, complete with a new calendar centered on his person and a sense that the old age had passed and a new one arrived. Not only that, but “the earliest Christians seem to have used a characteristically Augustan approach to time” (112), regarding themselves as the fulfillment of Jewish prophecies much as (say) Virgil saw the Romans as the true heirs of Homeric Greece. Readers may quibble with Whitmarsh’s use of “supersessionism” in this context, but the comparison is fascinating and well drawn.

When we situate the early church within this world, its growth, influence, and missionary strategy all make good historical sense, as Whitmarsh shows in part 3.

Within Greco-Roman communities, and cities in particular, Christian leaders would have been recognizable as Charismatics, religious experimenters competing for success within a deregulated religious market; as Experts, presenting themselves as philosophers with “a coherent system of wisdom that competed with, indeed far outdid, the various Greek philosophical schools” (148); as Bibliophiles, writing and reading books because they operated in a literate world; and as Zealots, with their violent and heroic stories of martyrdom. There are even points of overlap between Greek novels and early Christian thought, once again with influence flowing in both directions.

Occasional Overstatements

Though the book is generally balanced in tone, occasionally it strays into overstatement or factual error.

It’s a stretch to say that Jesus’s original teachings are “lost forever” because we only have them in Greek translation (xix); it’s simply untrue to say that “we do not, of course, have a single word securely attributed to Jesus, who spoke only Aramaic” (37), in light of well-known examples like “talitha koum,” “ephphatha,” “Abba,” “Cephas,” “Boanerges,” “mammon,” and “Eloi, Eloi, lema sabachthani.”

To be fair, some of Whitmarsh’s overstatements are standard fare among classicists who aren’t Christians: “The fact that the Christmas story is a fiction is well understood, and has been for hundreds of years” (92).

Though the book is generally balanced in tone, occasionally it strays into overstatement or factual error.

But some overstatements are more surprising and would be rejected by many in the scholarly guild: “It is a theme central to the theology of the Gospels: that the coming of Jesus . . . renders Jewish law obsolete” (111). Equally puzzling is his belief that Christians only met in private homes, not least because it comes right after citing a work (by my doctoral supervisor, no less) that demonstrates the reverse to be true.

Some errors are inexplicable, especially for a professor of Greek. His claim that “slave” is the dominant meaning of diakonos in the Septuagint (144) is completely upside down; diakonos only appears a handful of times, and never to translate eved, for which the translators usually use doulos or pais. More baffling still is the idea that the author of 1 Corinthians 7:3–5 was characterized by a “radical rejection of sex, even within wedlock” (221), when the text explicitly says the opposite.

Mostly, however, these problems are relatively minor and ancillary to the main argument. On the whole, Rome’s Age of Revolution is a tightly argued and fluently written book that makes a number of important connections between the Greco-Roman world and the formation of the early church, many of which would appear in a good biblical commentary.

Perhaps it’s the extravagant claims on the dustcover, and perhaps it’s just that I’ve read many good biblical commentaries, but my main reaction on finishing it was to ask, Is that it?

Read More

The Gospel Coalition

Generated by Feedzy